Spotify Vs. Apple Music Mobile Apps: A User Experience Case Study

There are many music streaming applications out there, and they’ve all been catering features that they think their users want or need. However, it’s hard to know the perfect balance without looking at two platforms side-by-side. This article highlights how the Apple user experience compares to Spotify’s.

Introduction to the Mobile Apps

If you’re a music lover, you’ve probably wondered about the differences between Spotify and Apple Music. Both platforms offer a great selection of tunes, but which one is better?

We’ll compare the user interface, design, features, and more to help you decide which app is better for you!

The Spotify app is available on both iOS and Android devices. It’s simple to use and has a clean design. The main menu consists of four tabs: Home, Browse, Search, and Your Library.

The Home tab contains your personalised recommendations based on your listening history. You can also access the latest releases and charts here.

The Browse tab lets you discover new music by genre, activity, or mood. You can also browse podcasts here.

The Search tab allows you to search for any artist, album, or song. You can also create your own custom playlists here.

Your Library is where all of your saved music is stored. This includes anything you’ve added to your collection and any playlists you’ve created.

The Apple Music app is only available on iOS devices. It has a similar design to the Spotify app but with some slight differences. For example, instead of four tabs at the bottom of the screen, there are three: For You, Browse, and Radio. 

Photos and First Impressions: What’s the Difference?

Like most people, you probably take your smartphone and post pictures online. But what if you want to listen to music on your phone?

First impressions are important but don’t always tell the whole story. When it comes to Spotify and Apple Music, both apps have their pros and cons. Which one you prefer will likely come down to personal preference.

Spotify has a clean interface with large icons that make it easy to navigate. However, some users complain that the app is slow to load and can be buggy sometimes. However, Spotify is a solid option for streaming music on your mobile device.

On the other hand, Apple Music has a more complex interface with smaller icons. Some users find this confusing and challenging to navigate. But others appreciate the wealth of options and features that Apple Music offers. In general, Apple Music is a good choice for those already familiar with using iTunes on their computer.

So which app should you use? It depends on what you’re looking for in a music streaming app. If you want something simple, go with Spotify. If you’re looking for more features and options, go with Apple Music.

Visual Design and Layout

Regarding streaming music, Spotify and Apple Music are two of the most popular platforms on the market. Both platforms offer a comprehensive music library, with millions of songs available to stream anytime. However, one area where these two streaming giants differ is in their mobile app design and layout.

Spotify’s Mobile App:

When you first open Spotify’s mobile app, you’re greeted by a colourful and clean interface. The main screen comprises large tiles that showcase featured playlists and new releases. Scrolling down reveals more playlists organised by genre, mood, or activity.

One thing we like about Spotify’s mobile app design is that it makes it easy to discover new music. The Featured section is constantly updated with new content, so you always see something fresh when you open the app. And if you’re not sure what you want to listen to, the browse function lets you explore Spotify’s massive library of songs by genre, mood, or activity.

Apple Music’s Mobile App:

Apple Music’s mobile app takes a different approach to visual design than Spotify. The main screen consists of a grid of round icons representing different content categories (e. g. For You, Browse, Radio, etc.). While this design may seem cluttered at first glance, it makes it easier to find the specific type of content you’re looking for.

If you’re unsure what to listen to, the For You section provides personalised recommendations based on your listening history. And if you just want to browse new releases and charts, the Browse section is a great starting point.

So, which platform has the better visual design and layout? We think it’s a close call between Spotify and Apple Music. Both platforms make it easy to discover new music, but we give the edge to Spotify because of its constantly-updated Featured section.

User Interface Design

Spotify and Apple Music are the most popular streaming music services available today. Both offer a mobile app for users to stream music on the go.

Spotify’s mobile app features a bottom navigation bar with icons for Home, Search, Your Library, and Premium. The home screen contains recent activity, featured playlists, and recommended songs. You can also access your playlists from the Your Library tab. The search function lets you search for artists, albums, or songs and browse by genre. The Premium tab lets you upgrade to a premium account or view the benefits of premium membership.

Apple Music’s mobile app has a similar bottom navigation bar with icons for For You, Browse, Radio, and My Music. The home screen (For You) contains personalised recommendations based on your listening history. The Browse section lets you explore new music by genre, artist, or album. The Radio tab allows you to access Beats 1 and other Apple Music radio stations. My Music is where you can find all of your saved songs, albums, and playlists.

Both Spotify and Apple Music have well-designed mobile apps that are easy to use. However, Spotify’s app feels more streamlined and more straightforward to navigate than Apple Music’s app.

Navigation and Organisation

We put both apps head-to-head in a user experience case study to find out. We looked at navigation, organisation, design, and functionality to see which app was more intuitive and user-friendly.

Here’s what we found:

Spotify has a more streamlined interface that is easy to navigate. There are fewer options and menus to sort through, so you can get to the music you want to listen to more quickly.

Apple Music’s interface is a bit more complex, with more options and sections to explore. While this can be overwhelming for some users, others may appreciate having more control over their listening experience.

Both apps allow you to create playlists and listen to radio stations, but Spotify offers a few more customization options. For example, you can choose whether or not you want your playlists to be collaborative or private, and you can add filters to radio stations so that they only play songs that fit your specific criteria.

Spotify also has a feature called “Discover Weekly,” which creates a custom playlist of new music for you every week based on your listening habits. This is a great way to find new artists and songs that you might like.

Apple Music does not have anything similar, but it does have “For You,” which recommends new music based on what you’ve previously listened to.

Regarding design, both apps are visually appealing and easy on the eyes. However, Spotify’s dark theme may be easier on your battery life and less likely to cause eye strain.

Overall, we think Spotify has the better user experience. It is more intuitive and user-friendly, with a streamlined interface that makes it easy to find the music you want to listen to.

Styling

It’s no secret that first impressions are essential. The same can be said about mobile app design and user experience. A study by Appboy found that 88% of users will delete an app after just one bad experience. With that stat in mind, let’s look at the styling of two popular streaming music apps – Spotify and Apple Music.

Both apps use clean, flat designs with large icons and typography. But that’s where the similarities end. Spotify has a more playful and colourful aesthetic, while Apple Music feels more polished and refined.

Spotify’s design relies heavily on whitespace to create a sense of openness and harmony. Their colour palette is composed mainly of greens, blues, and purples – colours that have been shown to reduce stress and promote relaxation. In contrast, Apple Music uses a lot of greys and blacks, giving it a more serious tone. 

It’s worth noting that the different styles of these apps reflect the overall branding of the companies. Spotify is known for being youthful and edgy, while Apple has always been seen as more upscale and mature. 

When it comes to usability, both apps are pretty straightforward to navigate. However, there are a few key differences worth mentioning. For example, Spotify allows you to see what songs are trending within your network of friends, whereas Apple Music shows you what’s popular across all users.

Conclusion

Ultimately, it comes down to what you value most in music streaming mobile apps. Apple Music might be your best choice if you place higher importance on things such as a sleek user interface or exclusive features. 

However, if you prioritise having an extensive music library and being able to customise your listening experience, Spotify would probably be a better fit.

Confetti Design Studio is an award winning creative design firm based in India. We work with companies around the world by providing them premium design solutions ranging from product design, web design & graphic design. Contact us right now so we can get started on your amazing idea and project.

Kanishka Bothra

Kanishka Bothra

Your Spotify Vs. Apple Music Mobile Apps: A User Experience Case Study experience is just one click away!